Best Dust Collector for Small SHop
While air quality and dust control keeps you healthy, your woodworking tools ALSO require dust collection to properly operate. Not sure what dust collector is best for your tools? Or what the best dust collector brands are? In this article learn what the right dust collector is for small and large workshops.
With so many health issues to watch for these days it’s a must that any woodworker invest in the right dust control.
And, to help keep my lungs clean and healthy, I’ve used everything from a cabinet shop dust collector that piped dust into a pile outside to my home workshops JET Canister Collector.
But choosing a dust collector isn’t easy as you’ll need to consider small micron filtration (hint: canisters perform best), make sure you have a high volume of air flow to each tool, use room filtration to capture dust after the tools are off, and of course fit your purchase into your shop size and budget.
In this article we’ll help you navigate the various types of dust collectors:
- Dust extractors that connect to your hand tools
- Dust cyclones to convert your shop vac to a dust collector
- Wall mounted dust collectors for small shops
- Compact collectors for stationing alongside tools
- Dust filtration systems that support your dust collector
- Professional sized dust collectors like the LAGUNA FLUX with HEPA
- Dust hoods for miter saws
Lastly, remember that with wood dust it’s the small micron dust that is a key concern. Dust collectors, filtration systems and masks all combine to help keep your lungs healthy in the long run.
|UPGRADE PICK: JET Vortex Canister for medium sized shops.||CHECK PRICE|
|BEST SMALL SHOP: POWERTECH wall mounted dust collector.||CHECK PRICE|
|FOR HAND TOOLS: Dewalt dust extractor for hand tools.||CHECK PRICE|
|AIR FILTRATION: Shop Fox air filtration for small micron, suspended particles.||CHECK PRICE|
|CYCLONE FILTER: in-line filtration to remove large chips.||CHECK PRICE|
|MITER SAW HOOD: use a hood to capture dust from this top dust producer||CHECK PRICE|
Best Dust Collector: Important Features
Like any tool, it’s best to understand all the possible features of a dust collector first.
While you won’t need or buy all of them, some features may spark an idea on how you can best install or utilize the dust collection system.
With that, here’s the top features to consider:
- Large particle dust control
- Air flow velocity
- Air flow volume (cubic feet per minute or CFM)
- Static pressure
- Portable vs. stationary
- Cyclonic dust collection
- Remote controlled vs. push button vs. automatic activation
- Fine particle filtration (cartridge vs. bag)
- Lastly, fine particle dust control is best left to a dust filtration system
Types of Dust Collectors
Now, as you know, not all dust collectors will pack all of these features into one. For example, larger shops demand more air movement (and horsepower) as machines are connected by runs of ducting.
But on the other hand, small home workshops may only need direct attachment to smaller table saws and hand tools.
All of this has brought dust collection for woodworkers into six distinct types of shop dust collection systems:
1. Shop Vacuum Dust Collectors
Shown: Dewalt Shop Vacuum
Shop vacuum dust collectors utilize a shop vacuum and hoses connected directly to your machinery. While inexpensive, these systems are designed for smaller tools and usually require moving the hoses and vacuum when you switch tools.
The drawbacks of this system are fast clogging and filling of your main collection tank.
Which leads us to our next type of dust collector (well, technically, an add-on…).
2. Dust Separators
Shown: Dust Deputy
Dust separators are in a class of their own as they are add-ons that make a shop vacuum system work MUCH better.
While there are a variety of systems, including the extremely popular Dust Deputy, the basics of a separator is in it’s use of a cyclonic air movement that pulls heavy chips out and only passes finer dust upstream to your shop vacuum.
Seems optional, right? Not really, you’ll want to try one of these out to see why thousands of woodworkers rely on them.
3. Dust Extractors
Dust Extractors are gaining popularity as a stand-alone unit designed to pull dust from small hand tools. We’ll cover these in more detail later, but they are essentially a specialized shop vacuum designed only for hand tool dust.
Thinking you’ve seen these before but can’t remember where? Well, if you’re familiar with Festool tools like the Domino joiner you’ve likely seen their dust extractor.
Shown: Makita Dust Extractor
4. Bag System Single Stage Dust Collectors
Single stage bag dust collectors are the next step up from a shop vacuum. With a simple design, larger horsepower, and ability to connect to multiple tools these are great choices for small workshops.
And, they come in wall mount, hand-held portable or classic upright design (like the cartridge version coming up next).
Shown: Shop Fox Wall Dust Collector
5. Canister System Single Stage Dust Collectors
Canister dust collectors are distinct enough from a bag that separating them into their own type of dust collector is worth it.
While a bag system inflates and deflates, a cartridge system is static and it’s grooved fin design offers greater surface area for filtering dust. And, they are generally able to capture more 1 and 2-micron dust particles.
Every 30 minutes or so I like to spin the agitator paddle to remove any built-up dust that is prevent maximum suction.
Editors note: the Jet Dust Collector pictured above is what I’ve used in my workshop for almost 20 years.
Shown: Jet Canister Dust Collector
6. Cyclonic Industrial Dust Collectors
Cyclonic dust collectors are the king of dust collectors as they feature two-stage dust separation and the most cubic feet of air flow.
While you may have seen larger units parked on top of industrial buildings, these have been shrunk down to size to fit into most larger workshops.
Why a cyclone? Well, the air movement allows large particles to fall to the bottom and out into a large chip container. Meanwhile, smaller particles are suspended and pushed into a neighboring collection bin that collects the fine “cake dust” into a smaller bag.
7. Large Shop Dust Collectors
When it comes to large workshops that will run multiple tools with high CFM requirements then the game steps up to more power.
And while most small workshop dust collectors start at 1HP, these units start at 3HP and go to 6HP or more. Which means 30 to 50-amp breakers and specialized power to handle heavy workloads.
Of course, these systems are all meant to be ducted and the top brands like Laguna offer up HEPA filtration.
Trouble finding the right dust collector and accessories? Check out Woodcraft for a great selection. And, for some tools, they offer up a regular 10% discount for new buyers.
Choosing the Best Dust Collector for Your Shop
First, classification is everything in tools.
For example, I wouldn’t recommend a 2-car garage woodworker to buy an industrial sized SawStop table saw as it’s likely both out of your budget and you won’t have room for it.
So, instead, we’ll take a look at the best dust collector based on your shop size and your likely tools.
Shop Vacuum Dust Collector for Small Shops
There are tens of thousands of home workshops using a shop vacuum to collect dust.
And, using a shop vacuum is an ok approach if you are starting out.
Will a shop vacuum work as good as a $700 dust collector? No. But, if you already own a shop vacuum you can start containing your dust issues by simply adding a dust separator.
With that in mind, here are the key things to look for in a shop vacuum dust collector:
- Largest possible CFM (cubic feet per minute)
- Highest horsepower
- Extra long hose to allow movement between machines
- High quality hose that won’t kink or break
- Ideally cart based and not the clumsy, short push-and-kick around models in home stores
No matter how good your shop vacuum is you HAVE to use an upstream dust separator to avoid loss of suction caused by a clogged shop vacuum filter.
Best SHop Vacuum for Dust Collection
While a wall mounted option in a shop vacuum is one way to go just remember you’ll need to have it close to your tools. And in suction, distance equals loss of power.
Which means a floor model is your best bet.
But, if you’re like me, you’ve fought and tripped over the standard portable shop vacuums on simple jobs like vacuuming the truck.
Which is why the “Beast Series” from Vacmaster (above) is a place to start that features:
- For a shop vacuum, a massive 123 Cubic Feet Per Minute (CFM)
- 14 gallon tank
- 6.5HP motor
- 27 feet of total reach with extension cord and hose
- And, of course, a CART to move it around
Don't Lose Suction: Use a Dust Separator With ALL Shop Vacuums
Once you have your shop vacuum, you’ll need to add a dust separator to make it work properly.
Fortunately, these don’t break the bank and can be had for a reasonable price.
Maybe you’d like to skip this step and just “try it out”? Well, you’ll face the frustrating issue of loss of suction. So, use one of these two options instead:
Small Shop Single Stage Dust Collectors
If you total up the price of a shop vacuum that moves a lot of air PLUS the cost of a secondary cyclone you’ll probably come close to $200.
So is there another option?
A single stage dust collector that will give you over 500 CFM of airflow and run you a total of $200-250.
Key small dust collector features:
- Wall mounted or portable on casters
- 2 micron collection bags (make sure it has a zipper!)
- 4″ hoses vs. 2.5″ found on shop vacuums
Beware of generic brands that skimp on the basics like zippers on the collection pouch.
Important note: even a small single stage dust collector can generate 4-6x the air flow of a shop vacuum. Which means you can reduce airborne dust.
Wall Mounted Dust Collector
A wall mounted collector, like the name brand Shop Fox W1826 , will upgrade your dust collection over a shop vacuum. And, as these unites are designed for dust collection will avoid the issues of clogged lines from large chips.
For installation, these units simply hang on the wall and connect up to your machines with a standard 4″ dust hose.
Best of all? With these units lower cost you can buy 2 or 3 and spread around your shop to avoid running ducts (that can lose power over long distances).
Portable Single Stage Dust Collector
If your tools are more spread out and you need to move the dust collector to the tools then this Rikon Portable dust collector is a great place to start. And, this unit has an added bonus of converting to a wall mount when you don’t need portability. Great for storage.
While a longer hose with a wall mounted tool is an option, the longer the hose the less suction you’ll have.
And, remembering short tools will be a stumbling hazard, this unit has a tall stance with a slick holder for your hose when not in use.
Best Dust Collector System for a Larger Workshop
If you have the room for a larger dust collector that can be ducted to your tools it’s a great investment.
And with a larger motor and more surface area on the bags or canisters a full size dust collector will put you over 1000 CFM.
- Large collection bags (30-50 gallons)
- 1000+ CFM of air movement
- Able to connect to multiple tools
- Supports ducting over shorter runs
- Most allow for two 4″ or one 6″ hoses
- Optional canister systems for better fine dust control
- Portable for moving around the shop
If you have the room and budget this is a big purchase, but with the higher air volume you’ll capture more dust.
Just remember to install gates if you use ducting to limit airflow to one tool at a time.
Best Large Dust Collector
While there are a variety of brands on the market (Grizzly, Shop Fox, Powermatic) this is one area of the market that Jet Tools has dominated. Until you move up to an industrial, cabinet-shop grade unit with built-in cyclones you won’t find much variations among units.
So, I go with a brand I trust.
- Support for 4″ or 6″ dust hoses
- Large dust bags
- Canister (preferred) or bags with at least 2.5 micron filtration
- 1.5 HP or more
- 1100 or more CFM
- Lower noise (less than 80 decibels a must)
Lastly, not many woodworkers know about this device, but be sure to add a Automated Vacuum Switch to your dust collector. It will turn your vacuum on when you turn on you tools.
Dust Collectors For Miter Saws
After spending a few months building an outdoor accessory building, re-doing my deck and even cutting aluminum hand railings my Makita miter saw was busy.
And, it generated a MASSIVE pile of dust. Since I was in the middle of upgrading my miter saw station I hadn’t yet installed a dust collection hood.
Dust Collection Hoods for Miter Saws
As you can see pictured above, a dust collection hood simply fits around the back of your saw like a hood. Since you likely know your miter saw dust can NEVER be caught by the (silly) dust collection bag, these hoods work to capture all of the dust.
And, when paired with your dust collection system (there’s a hookup at the bottom back of the bag) you’ll be able to capture a high volume of that dust.
Dust Extractors vs. Dust Collectors
All of this is great, you might say, but how do I control the dust of my hand tools?
With a dust extractor of course.
Where a dust collector is all about large volumes of air, a dust extractor is built for high suction. And convenience with features like:
- Automated on/off to start and stop with your tools
- Long, small diameter hose to work with your tools
- Portability for use in the garage, home or on the jobsite
- Lower decibel than a shop vacuum
- Power plug on the machine to detect and enable the dust extractor to start/stop
The Best Dust Collector System Requires Accesories
Once you have a decision made on the best dust collector for your shop you’ll want to take a look at a few additions.
While easy to either overlook, or just not know they are available, here’s a few to consider:
- Extra dust hose
- Floor sweep chute
- Pre-piping on tools with hard-to-reach dust ports (table saw)
- Ducting supplies and reducers (router table)
- Extra dust collection bags
- Hand tool adapter hoses
- And, the most innovative item, a switch that will automatically turn your dust collector on & off when a connected tool is installed
Frequently Asked Questions
How much CFM do I need for a dust collector?
In general you’ll want a dust collector that can produce at least 500 cfm. Since you’ll lose suction to hose length, fine dust cake that accumulates on your bag, and simply some tools that just require 400-500 CFM. While this rules out a shop vacuum for most larger tools like a planer, if you are looking for dust collection with a smaller hand tools a 100-150 CFM shop vacuum can work.
How much does a dust collector cost?
A small shop vacuum dust collector with a dust separator can start around $125 and run all way up to $700 for a larger shop dust collector. Industrial dust collection units typically start at $1500 and cost upwards of tens of thousands of dollars for large furniture shops.
Do I need an air filtration system if I have a dust collector?
It’s always best to pair an air filtration system with a dust collector. Since a dust collector only captures dust in range of it’s suction you will not collect the fine particles that hang in the air. The air filtration systems, however, will circulate the air in your workshop and collect dust that remains suspended for up to 30 minutes.
Is a single stage or cyclonic dust collector better?
A cyclonic dust collector is generally better than a single stage dust collector as it separates heavy particles early and allows separated collection of large and fine particles.
While choosing the best dust collector for your workshop and tools isn’t always easy, hopefully this article shed some light on where to invest.
Last update on 2021-10-15 at 02:14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API